Tradecraft
The google search method I employ regularly to wander around sources for (mostly) academic research has two components.
1. [filetype] filetype:pdf finds acrobat files
2. [parentheses]
For example:
filetype:pdf “theory of mind” “folk psychology” controversy
uncovers academic papers that contain the extremely common wedding of folk psychology, with, theory of mind. And, by adding controversy to the search terms, papers about controversies rise to the top.
After decades of reading refereed papers, the heuristic options have been narrowed down to familiar (to me) kinds of markers. So, controversy is a superior search term to, for example, disagreement.
(Interestingly, the filetype:pdf search proves valuable because Acrobat is the file type that lends itself to researcher’s posting papers on their web sites in a format that can’t easily be messed with; is, in many respects, a facsimile. In contrast to this, filetype:doc for Word files, doesn’t bring up as high quality results.)
If a correspondent or colleague presents an assertion in absolutist terms, it is safe to say that my first knee jerk reaction, irrespective of whether or not I can instantly frame this type of assertion, is to venture via search to learn if, in fact, the assertion is controversial.
I added David Chalmer’s portal of research, Mind Papers, to the Sites of Interest sidebar.
It’s folk psychology, I mean Folk Psychology, section has the following TOC:
Read the rest of this entry »
1. [filetype] filetype:pdf finds acrobat files
2. [parentheses]
For example:
filetype:pdf “theory of mind” “folk psychology” controversy
uncovers academic papers that contain the extremely common wedding of folk psychology, with, theory of mind. And, by adding controversy to the search terms, papers about controversies rise to the top.
After decades of reading refereed papers, the heuristic options have been narrowed down to familiar (to me) kinds of markers. So, controversy is a superior search term to, for example, disagreement.
(Interestingly, the filetype:pdf search proves valuable because Acrobat is the file type that lends itself to researcher’s posting papers on their web sites in a format that can’t easily be messed with; is, in many respects, a facsimile. In contrast to this, filetype:doc for Word files, doesn’t bring up as high quality results.)
If a correspondent or colleague presents an assertion in absolutist terms, it is safe to say that my first knee jerk reaction, irrespective of whether or not I can instantly frame this type of assertion, is to venture via search to learn if, in fact, the assertion is controversial.
I added David Chalmer’s portal of research, Mind Papers, to the Sites of Interest sidebar.
It’s folk psychology, I mean Folk Psychology, section has the following TOC:
Read the rest of this entry »


